A good pin is a metal drawing you can feel. A weak pin is sloppy paint and a soft post. A quality walk, not a scare. You are looking at the back stamp, the post, and whether color stayed in the cell.
Hard, soft, cloisonne, pewter, mystery
Hard enamel fills to the metal line, then gets ground so color and brass meet in one plane. Soft enamel leaves the line standing and the color lower. Cloisonne is the older jewelry word for color in a metal cell. Pewter is a cast silhouette without a baked color field. A mystery pack is a sealed bag of mixed faces. You buy the surprise. You do not buy a promise about which face is inside.
None of those finishes is a fake. They are different jobs. Hard enamel is the jewelry face. Soft enamel is the tactile drawing. Pewter is the silhouette. Mystery is a bag of extras for a trade book. Read how an enamel pin is made for the bake and the clutch.
What to look at
Turn the pin over. A licensed metal trade pin usually carries a copyright stamp in the back. Park booths use that mark as the main test for a tradable pin. A blank back is a reason to keep the pin on your jacket and off a staff board.
The post should be straight and tight in the body. A wobbly needle bends in a bag and then chews cloth. The clutch should match the pin. A heavy 3-inch hard-enamel face wants a rubber or locking clutch. A light flag pin is fine on a butterfly.
Look at the color from the side. Hard enamel should be flush. Soft enamel should sit in the cell, not blob over the wall. Paint that floods the line is a factory miss, not a finish. A little dust in a soft-enamel trench wipes off. A ridge of paint on top of the brass does not.
Mystery packs and extras
A mystery bag is useful when you want volume for park trades. Open it at the hotel. Check backs and posts before you walk into a park pin shop. If a face is bent or the stamp is missing, keep it as a jacket pin. Do not argue with booth staff about it.
Licensed character pins from Amazon are still Amazon listings. Ratings move. A 4.5 with two hundred reviews tells you more than a five with none. Get this opens that row. This page does not grade authenticity. We tell you what the metal should look like.
Get this Licensed trading figure pin. A 3-inch hard-enamel face with a display case and a serial number.
Get this Licensed trading figure pin. A 3-inch hard-enamel face with a serial number.
Get this Beach sunset surfboard pin. A 1.75-inch enamel surfboard. Check the line against the color.
Side-by-side finish is on hard enamel vs souvenir. The shop wall is here.
Cloisonne and the word fake
People say cloisonne when they mean hard enamel. True cloisonne is jewelry wire cells filled with glass. A park pin is usually enamel on brass or zinc. Call it hard or soft. The back stamp still matters more than the word.
Rubber and PVC faces exist. Park booths that trade metal want a copyright mark on the back. A rubber souvenir can live on your bag. It will not trade on a staff lanyard. That is a rule, not a quality insult.
Overfill is the usual factory miss. Color climbs the wall and dulls the line. Shallow cells look hungry. A clean cell has a sharp brass edge you can see from the side. A sloppy cell is a miss, not a counterfeit. We call it a miss. Keep it, wear it at home, or leave it off the park board.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Shop rows link one Amazon listing each. Prices and ratings are Amazon's and change without notice.
Publisher: Orlando Pin Company and Tabaconda LLC. Write sales@tabaconda.com.